Selection Criteria
Winter Training Squads
This selection policy applies to the selection of Middlesex Golf Squads. Performance Squads will benefit from away days during the winter and other experiences that the County will provide. These away days should occur about twice during the winter, depending on the coaching budget. The Academy Squads will receive group coaching about three times during the winter season from the County, depending on budget.
Purpose
The purpose of this policy is to establish a clear, transparent and accountable system of selection for all Middlesex Golf Squads, to ensure so far as possible that criteria is objective and fully understood by players, parents/guardians, coaches, team managers and all interested parties.
The policy also aims to:
- Set out the conditions of selection
- Identify the objectives of the Middlesex Golf Teams & Coaching Committee
- Identify the selection process, criteria and key timescales for selection for Middlesex Golf Squads
- Identify the appeals process should an individual(s) believe this policy has not been implemented
Conditions of Selection
For players to be selected on a Middlesex Golf Squad (Academy or Performance) they must meet the following conditions:
- be eligible to play golf for Middlesex
- be a home member of an affiliated club of Middlesex
- not be subject to any disciplinary process or sanction by Middlesex Golf
- Signed the Middlesex Golf Code of Conduct prior to the first coaching session
Availability
- Upon selection to a Squad, the player must confirm their availability for all Squad Sessions.
Middlesex Golf Teams & Coaching Committee Objectives
The objectives of the Middlesex Golf Teams & Coaching Committee are to:
- Select Middlesex Golf Squads at all levels using the criteria set out
- Middlesex Golf Teams & Coaching committee pledge that whatever your reason for playing the game, we will foster that passion and encourage you to play and love the game in your own unique way. If you aspire to be one of the greatest that has ever played the game, we want to facilitate your path to the top. If playing County golf is your goal, we want to help you taste success along the way. Regardless of what your goals in the game are, we want every golfer that has been selected by the County to be able to say that they have learned lessons that are not only applicable to golf, but also to life.
- To ensure that future playing potential as well as current achievement remains a key factor in the selection process of Middlesex Golf Squads.
- Ensure players that are unsuccessful in Squad or team selection are provided with feedback by Middlesex Golf
Overall Selection for Middlesex Golf Squads
Overall, selections will be made based on three primary areas. The Middlesex Golf Teams & Coaching Committee will require players to achieve strong ratings in at least two of the following criteria to be considered for selection:
- Tournament Results outside of the player’s home club
- Coaching Report from Middlesex County Coaches
- Manager’s report
- Handicap Index
Additionally, a players’ selection to a Squad will also be dependent on whether they possess the below characteristics to varying degrees:
- Commitment
- Ownership
- Time-Management
- Resilience
- Physical Fitness
- Mental Strength
- Technical Skills
Those players selected for Squads may enter be selected at any time and do not need to have been on an Academy Squad before progressing to a Performance Squad.
Middlesex Golf Championships
It is acknowledged that Academy Squad player selection will have a greater emphasis on Talent ID structures but for the Performance Squad, strong weighting will be placed on performances in Championships, therefore players wishing to be considered for selection are expected to compete in Middlesex Golf Championships throughout the season.
Performance Squads
Performance squads include:
- Girls’ U18’s Performance Team
- Boys’ U18’s Performance Team A
- Boys’ U18’s Performance Team B
- Women’s Performance Team
- Men’s 1st & Colts’ Performance Team
- Men’s Senior Performance Team
- Women’s Senior League Performance Team
As part of the decision-making process the Teams & Coaching Committee will also consider a players’ tournament statistics outside of England.
Overall Aim
To improve upon the already considerable abilities of the high-performance players and assist them towards excelling in national amateur golf while representing Middlesex.
Overall Objectives
- Create an environment which exposes players to experiences, conditions, surroundings, and ideas that they are not exposed to at club level
- Supports players to focus on the controllables as they strive to achieve excellence
- Supply players with access to a highly responsive coaching system, delivered by experienced and professional coaching staff, with an excellent track record of success and innovation
- Design training plans that meet the individual needs of the player and complementary competition schedules
Girls U18 Criteria for consideration:
- Home Club in Middlesex
- WAGR Ranking
- Performances in National Championships (i.e. English Girls closed, English Girls Open, etc.)
- County performances (U26, U18, U16, U14 Championships, etc.)
- Club Open performances (Muswell Hill Junior Open, etc.)
- Typically, Handicap Index of 13.4 or better
Boys
U18 Criteria for consideration:
Team A
- Home Club in Middlesex
- WAGR Ranking
- National performances (Boys Amateur Championship, etc.)
- County performances (U26, U18, U16, U14 Championships, etc.)
- Club Open performances (Muswell Hill Junior Open, etc.)
- Typically, Handicap Index of 7.0 or better
Team B
- Home Club in Middlesex
- County performances (U26, U18, U16, U14 Championships, etc.)
- Club Open performances (Muswell Hill Junior Open, etc.)
- Typically, Handicap Index of 9.4 or better
Women’s Team Criteria for consideration:
- Home Club in Middlesex
- WAGR Ranking
- National performances (English Women’s amateur Championship, etc.)
- County performances (Women’s County Championship, etc)
- Typically, Handicap Index of 12.4 or better
Men’s Team Criteria for consideration:
- Home Club in Middlesex
- WAGR Ranking
- National performances (English Amateur Championship, etc.)
- County performances (Men’s County Championship, etc)
- Club Open performances (Sudbury Salver, etc.)
- Typically, Handicap Index of 2.4 or better
Men’s Senior Team Criteria for consideration:
- Home Club in Middlesex
- National performances (English Amateur Championship, etc.)
- County performances (Senior County Championship, etc)
- Club Open performances (Sudbury Salver, etc.)
- Typically, Handicap Index of 5.4 or better
Women’s Senior Team Criteria for consideration:
- Home Club in Middlesex
- National performances (English Senior Women’s Open, etc)
- County performances (Senior County Championship)
- Typically, Handicap Index of 9.4 or better
Academy Squads
Academy squads include:
- Girls’ U18’s Academy Team
- Boys’ U18’s Academy Team
- Women’s Academy Team
- Men’s Senior Academy Team
- Women’s Senior Friendlies Academy Team
Aim
To bring skilful players together in a social and creative environment where they can thrive and further develop their talents.
Objectives
- To create an environment where players can socialise and develop their skills with players of similar standards
- Coaching sessions with a nominated PGA professional to develop short game skills, on course skills and technique
- To continue to advance players’ skill development and independent learning
- To prepare players for the playing season in 2021
- To increase players’ awareness on playing opportunities available to them at Regional & National events
Girls U18 – Academy Squad
- Domestic performances (U18, U16 & U14 Championships)
- Typically, Handicap Index of 21.4 or better
Boys U18 – Academy Squad
- County performances (U18, U16 & U14 Championships)
- Typically, Handicap Index of 12.4 or better
Women’s Team – Academy Squad
- Domestic performances (Middlesex Championships)
- Typically, Handicap Index of 15.4 or better
Women’s Senior Friendlies Team – Academy Squad
- Domestic performances (Middlesex Championships)
Men’s Senior Team – Academy Squad
- Domestic performances (Middlesex Championships)
- Typically, Handicap Index of 6.4 or better
Selection Date, Notification & Announcement
The selection of County Performance and Academy Development Squads for the 2020/21 coaching season will be announced and published by the end of 2020.
Transition
A player may be moved onto or off a squad during a season and may also move up and down the pathway between Academy and Performance Squads. These decisions will be based on but not limited to; personal development/progress across all levels of support (golfing coaching, strength & conditioning, mental skills and lifestyle management), levels of commitment to coaching sessions and designated tournaments listed by Middlesex Golf coaches, attendance and behaviour of players and performances in tournaments.
Appeals Process
If an individual believes that this policy has not been implemented correctly during the selection of a Squad, the individual concerned has the right to appeal against any such decision.
An appeal must be submitted in writing by the player (or parent) making the appeal which should contain details of the decision against which the appeal is being lodged and the full grounds of grievance (Notice of Appeal). The appeal must be addressed to the Director of Teams & Coaching, Middlesex Golf Ltd, Sudbury Golf Club, Bridgewater Road, Wembley, HA0 1AL and submitted within 5 working days following announcement of the Squad for which the appeal is being made.
Middlesex Golf will then endeavour to have any appeal heard within 10 working days of receipt of said appeal. The Middlesex Golf Director of Teams and Coaching will first determine whether there are legitimate grounds for appeal. These grounds may include but are not necessarily limited to;
- The decision taken was explicitly unreasonable based on the evidence before the Teams & Coaching Committee
- Significant, relevant new evidence has become available which was not available to the Teams & Coaching Committee but which could have been available at the time of the decision, and, had it been available, may have caused the Teams & Coaching Committee to reach a fundamentally different decision
- There were serious procedural or other irregularity in the selection proceedings
Should there be legitimate grounds for an appeal, an Appeal Committee will then be formed to manage the appeal. For Academy or Performance Squad Appeals, this Committee will be comprised of:
- Director of Teams and Coaching
- Team Manager
- County Coach
No member of an Appeals Committee shall have been involved directly in the selection decision being appealed.
This Appeals Committee will then follow an appeals process and it will decide whether to reject the appeal, or fully uphold the appeal, which will then be immediately communicated to the Appellant. It will also specify what action should then take place.